This isn’t the first time Lil’ D and Mrs. F have had a showdown on this blog but it’s hard to count one or the other out since I’ve only evaluated these against each other twice and bot have been a winner and a loser.
I think back about how disgusting it was to have the Little Deb version of these in the kitchen closet at all times when I was growing up. They were “Hebrew school friendly” and a common snack to bring to three hours of passing notes and flinging whatever we had in our Trapper Keepers around the room.
Opening these individually wrapped cookies releases a Twinkie-like aroma, which is artificial but sweet and characteristic of a mass-produced “bakery” treat.
The cookie is nice and moist and slightly reminiscent of an actual oatmeal cookie. Ethan and I each had a cookie/pie and he asked “what are these supposed to filled with? Marshmallow?” I always thought it was supposed to be something resembling whipped creme but more stable. I guess it’s really more of a frosting than a creme or a marshmallow but somehow doesn’t add too much to the cookies but they okay. Ethan described these as “inoffensive”.
Mrs. F’s cookies were a little bit dryer, although in comparison to Lil’ D’s ultral moist and slightly oily cookies, this wasn’t a surprise. Also the texture and taste were more “oatmealy” and there was more creme that had a bit more vanilla flavor to it. Ethan said these tasted “more honest” and I agreed that these provided at least more of an illusion of eating an actual oatmeal cookie.
Mrs. Freshly wins this round bringing the score on this blog to her winning two out of three Little Debbie/Mrs. Freshly battles. I really thought after the Buddy Bar disappointment Mrs. F would forever be the second-rate snack, but after the donut stick challenge, she proved her self as a worthy opponent and slowly gaining credibility in the snack competitions.
4 thoughts on “Oatmeal Creme Pies vs Oatmeal Cremes”
Mmmm.. I wish they sold those Freshly’s around my way! And about those Oatmeal Pies. I swear they used to be bigger…???
The Little Debbie Pies seem to have changed since I was a kid. It’s almost like they have this weird chemical taste now that wasn’t there before. Shame. I used to love them.
I haven’t tried the Mrs. Freshley’s yet. Maybe I should suck it up and get a box to see if they’re acceptable.
I tried the Oatmeal Pies and to me they taste fake. I will keep a look out for Mrs Freshleys.
I think that Little Debbie is the only kind they have around here. I think I’m wrong,but I’ll see if I’m right or a bit koo-koo in the head.